MITCHELL COUNTY GENEALOGY

 

* * * * 1934 PLANE CRASH AT ST. ANSGAR KILLS FIVE * * * *

(The crash is believed to have happened in the middle of Church street
between 5th and 6th streets.)

 

Courier Article

Avalanche Article

Mason City Globe Gazette Photos

Mason City Globe Gazette - Article #1

Mason City Globe Gazette - Article #2

 










 


 

Lubbock, Texas
Morning Avalanche
July 5, 1934

 


 


Mason City Globe Gazette
July 5, 1934

 


Mason City Globe Gazette
July 5, 1934
Top photo from above front page

This airplane skeleton and mass of wreckage in front of the Borchardt apartment house in southeast St. Ansgar constituted a pyre late Wednesday for a pilot and four passengers who had hoppped off five minutes previously from a pasture a quarter mile east of that town. Guards within a roped area on the street kept watch over the scene Wednesday night in preparation for an inquiry by state authorities. The plane started it's fatal plunge almost over the business section of the town where a July 4 celebration was under way. It barely missed an electric light wire and one wing snapped off the top of a small hard maple tree just before, propeller foremost, the heavy 220 horsepower Wright Whirlwind motor** in the Ryan cabin plane burrowed into the street at the edge of a sidewalk.

NOTES:

** The Wright Whirlwind 220 hp engine is very likely a Wright R-790 9-cylinder piston engine, first built in 1923. Click on photo to see larger version. (Photos from Museum of the US Air Force and Wikipedia.com)

 

 


Mason City Globe Gazette
July 5, 1934
Pilot - Fred Symington

Fred Symington, 35, Ackley, is shown beside one of the planes he piloted in his career as aviator. He was doing a prosperous business taking up July fourth celebrators at St. Ansgar before he and four passengers were carried to their death in a disaster which stands as the worst in the history of North Iowa aeronautics.

 


Mason City Globe Gazette
July 5, 1934
Passengers

     Marvin Miller       Gladys Ueker         Ed Libersky       Vaney Libersky

The passengers who died in the crash of Symington's plane were two brothers, Ed Libersky, 36, and Vaney, 30, Miss Gladys Ueker, 20, the Globe-Gazette's correspondent at Grafton, and Marvin Miller, 20, also of Grafton (All Engravings by Kayenay).

 


Mason City Globe Gazette
July 5, 1934
Story No. 1

Crash of Airplane Turns Celebration to Tragedy

Ackley Aviator and 4 Other North Iowans Are Victims

ST. ANSGAR, July 5. — A motor sputtered, a large plane dipped from side to side and plunged precipitously downward, shrieks pierced the air from occupants of the falling ship—a tremendous crash, a burst of flame! And this community's day of joyous celebration, almost in the twinkling of an eye, had been converted into a night of profound sorrow.

Five young lives—four men and one girl—had been snuffed out in the worst aviation tragedy ever experienced in North Iowa.

The dead:

Fred Symington, 35, Ackley, pilot.
Gladys Ueker, 20, Grafton.
Marvin Miller, 20, Grafton.
Ed Libersky, 36, St. Ansgar.
Vaney Libersky, 30, St. Ansgar.

Wednesday night as St. Ansgar went through the motions of completing its Fourth of July celebration, the crash which carried a barnstorming pilot and his four passengers to their death, after a brisk day of business, was the topic of hushed conversation in dozens of groups.

Music Became a Dirge.

There was brave effort to enter into the spirit of a bowery dance but the presence nearby of the charred and twisted remains of the ill-fated airplane made a dirge of all music. Thoughts were on the five bodies, burned almost beyond recognition -- in

[Page 3 continuation]

the Schroeder and Houg funeral home in St. Ansgar and the Champion Funeral home in Osage —- and of the grief-stricken families.

The community was stunned, even as it was some five or six years ago when an unexplained blast at a filling station cost the lives of two well known citizens.

Happened at 5 O'clock.

Eye witnesses were piecing together their versions of the flight from the time the Ryan cabin plane, powered by a 220 Wright whirlwind motor, took off from a meadow on Hume's farm, a quarter of a mile east of town on highway 218, until the plane faltered as it was about to begin its regular descent, crashing into fragments and fire on the street in front of Borchardt's apartments in the southeast section of town.

The tragedy occurred at almost even 5 o'clock.

Although all evidence of a conclusive nature died with the pilot and passengers, some held to the hope that an investigation scheduled for today would throw some light on the catastrophe.

Several reports concerning the air-worthiness of the plane were being discussed. One was that the materials in it had disintegrated because of extended disuse. Another was that the plane was carrying an over-load. It was expected that the inquiry would dip into these matters.

Tree Was Cut Off.

Wreckage of the plane, covered over with a tarpaulin, was roped off and guarded Wednesday night. Curious persons were attracted to the scene by the hundreds while the gasoline fed flames were leaping tree high and throughout the evening but in anticipation of the inquiry were barred from touching the skeleton of the plane.

One of the points commented on by visitors to the scene was the decapitation of a small hard maple tree by one wing just before the plane nosed into the street at the edge of the sidewalk. The falling craft is said to have missed an electric light wire on the west side of the street by a matter of inches.

Eye Witness Story

Perhaps the fall of the plane and its conversion into a pyre can be most graphically described by letting the eye witness closest at hand tell his story here as he did late Wednesday night to a Globe-Gazette reporter—a witness who thought his own son might be in the catapulting ship.

It is Dr. W.L. Dockstader talking and a severe burn across his nose and front cheeks will bear testimony to his proximity to the wreckage when it burst into flame. "I was sitting in a chair on. the front lawn of my home, a block north and a block west of where the plane crashed. My brother-in-law, J. P. Hanson of Otranto, was seated in a car and we were watching the Ackley man's airplane as it circled over town on its numerous trips with passengers. I was especially interested because my 15 year old boy, Wilmer. Jr., was planning to go up some time during the afternoon.

Thought Pilot Was Stunting.

"On this final flight, I was attracted by an apparent flopping sidewise of the plane's wings, following a sputtering of the motor. I had felt all along that the pilot was flying too low but on this trip he seemed to have reached a great altitude. But I thought when the plane's course became a little unsteady that the pilot was doing a little stunting and I said something to my brother-in-law about the folly of such a thing.

"He isn't stunting," Mr. Hanson replied. "He's falling."

"As I look back on it, I can vaguely recall a noise from the plane, not unlike that of a crank arm coming loose in an automobile. It also seems now that I saw two or three objects released from the plane—I wondered if maybe they were firecrackers being thrown out. This part of my recollection is more or less hazy.

Thought of His Son.

"Immediately I had visions of my son in. a falling plane. I was terrified for an instant. Then I began to run in the direction of the plane's fall, across neighbors' yards.

"At the instant the plane hit the earth, I was within two rods of the wreckage. The next instant before the struts had quit quivering—I was at the wreckage, working feverishly to extricate from it a lad I thought might be my own. I have since identified it as Marvin Miller, He was slouched over so that I couldn't see his face. A door on this left side had been thrown open by the force of the crash and I tugged with all my might at the lad's arm.

Driven Away by Flames.

"Fire broke out immediately on the wing away from me and before I knew it, the flames were all around me. Mr. Hanson had overtaken me by this time and was tugging at me, realizing both the danger and the futility of the thing I was trying to do. I said something about the possibility of my boy being in the wreckage and tried anew to recover the body. But the flames had attained such intensity by this time that I had to give up.

"It wasn't until folks arrived from the landing field that I was assured my son had not been killed, that he had gone up on a hop earlier in the day."

Later still Dr. Dockstader felt a smarting sensation on his nose and and cheekbone. This, it developed, was caused by a large blistered area which was under a heavy coat of medicated cream Wednesday night.

Fire Fighters Called

The St. Ansgar fire department under the direction, of Chief W. B. Price swung into action but the wood and cloth material of the plane, some of it saturated with gasoline and oil, was so highly inflammable that nearly everything burnable was burned. Hose had to be strung a block and a half. So intense was the heat that a vine on the Borchardt apartments 40 feet distant was withered and scorched.

The flames extinguished, there began the tedious and unpleasant task of recovering the charred bodies from the cabin area of the large plane. C. P. Golberg and Vern Falk took a lead in this work. It wasn't until after 7 o'clock when the last body was removed. The job involved use of saws and sledges.

All Dead Before Fire.

Piteous shrieking of the passengers started, according to witnesses, soon after the plane obviously got out of control. No sound, however, came from the wreckage, leading to the belief that death was instant for all five passengers—and that they were spared the agony of death by incineration.

The Grafton party which set out for St. Ansgar for a day of merrymaking consisted of five. It was a quirk of circumstance that brought death to Gladys Ueker rather than to her lifelong friend, Pearl Borchert.

Yielded Her Turn to Ride.

Those in the party were Ivan Krueger, Miss Borchert and her sister, Ruby, Marvin Miller and Miss Ueker. Remembering that even riding on a ferris wheel or a merry-go-round made her dizzy, Miss Pearl Borchert yielded to Miss Ueker her invitation to accompany Marvin on the flight. Mr. Krueger and Miss Ruby had previously been up.

Wednesday night Miss Borchert was crushed with grief in the loss of a dear girl friend as well as of the man she was expected some day to marry.

Double Funerals

Plans for a double funeral for the Grafton air victims were laid Wednesday night by the Miller and Ueker families. It was to be held at 1:30 o'clock Thursday afternoon in the Grafton Lutheran Church, with the Rev. C. Landeck in charge.

Marvin Miller is survived by his parents, Mr. and Mrs. Herman Miller and a brother, Earl, manager of the local telephone company, by whom Marvin was also employed at times.

Miss Ueker leaves a father and mother, Mr. and Mrs. John Ueker and three younger sisters, Dorothy, Lola and Virginia. Gladys was employed at the Wagner meat market in Grafton. She served with distinction for several years as the Globe-Gazette's news representative in the Grafton community.

Fathers of the two victims, both high school graduates, have been associated as partners in the Miller-Ueker hardware store in Grafton since 1914.

Libersky Funeral Friday.

Double funeral rites for the Libersky brothers will be conducted Friday afternoon at the residence in St. Ansgar. Burial will be made in the St. Ansgar cemetery.

The Libersky brothers, both unmarried, were the sons of Mr. and Mrs. A. L. Libersky. The father is a retired farmer. The elder, son has been employed in maintenance work on the county highway system. Vaney, the younger brother, has been employed at times by H. B. Hansen in the local grain elevator.

The genius of the older brother in the manufacture of violins, despite his handicap of having only one arm, brought him considerable recognition. It was the steel hook which, took the place of the missing member that resulted in his identification, his body having been disfigured more than any of the other four victims. He had done considerable flying, it was stated by neighbors.

Four brothers and two sisters survive the Liberskys. The sisters are Mrs. Louis Volney and Mrs. Elmer Nelson, both of St. Ansgar: and the brothers are Joe, Lyle, Minn.; Frank, John and Charles of St. Ansgar.

Served in World War.

Mr. Symington was born Sept. 26. 1900. His father. Dr. Thomas Symington, died 21 yeahs ago. He was graduated from Ackley high school in 1916. After returning from service in the World war, he went to Whittier, Cal., where he operated a garage. In December. 1927. he returned to Ackley and had since worked as bookkeeper in the R. R. Hadley creamery

For the past three or four years Mr. Symington had been flying airplanes and last spring bought the airplane which crashed. It was bought at Waterloo and was not new. He was a licensed transport pilot.

His Mother's Support.

Mr. Symington, who was not married, had been supporting his mother, with whom he lived.

Besides his mother, Mrs. Anna Syminton, he is survived by one brother, Will, who is a salesman in the east; and his sisters, Mrs. R. R. Hadley of Ackley, Mrs. Arthur Hale of Nevada and Mrs. C. E. Mclatirc of I Pauline, 111. j

The body of Symington was taken early Thursday morning to the Greenfield funeral parlors at Ackley.

Funeral services for Mr. Symington will be held at 4 o'clock Friday afternoon at the residence. The Rev. W. E. Fisher, pastor of the Presbyterian church at Marion, will be in charge. The body will be placed in a crypt of a mausoleum. Harry Richsmeier, attorney at Ackley, was quoted by Ackley neighbors as having observed about two weeks ago that Symington said that if anything went wrong with the motor of his plane he would come down like a shot.

[MASON CITY GLOBE GAZETTE JULY 5, 1934]

 


 

Mason City Globe-Gazette
July 5, 1934
Story No. 2

MOTOR FAILURE SEEN AS CAUSE OF FATAL WRECK

Gatschet, Chairman of
Aeronautics Board,
Arrives at Scene.

ST. ANSGAR. July 5.— A representative of the state board of aeronautics came here today to investigate the airplane crash late Wednesday afternoon which carried five persons to their deaths. The site of the tragedy and the wreckage were guarded until his arrival.

Charles W. Gatschet of Des Moines, chairman of the state board of aeronautics, was named to investigate the crash. This was the first accident which the commission has been called upon to investigate since the new aeronautics law became effective June 1O. The commission's report will be filed with the adjutant general and federal authorities, it was stated in word received here from Des Moines.

Steps Not Revealed.

Various steps involved in the investigation were not revealed. An inspection of the debris and an order for the removal of the wreckage were expected from the commission representative.

Witnesses said they believed the motor of the plane sputtered several times while it was over the business district and that the pilot was attempting to land as quickly as possible with the failing motor when the crash occurred.

F. R. Shelledy of Qsage, coroner of Mitchell county, stated Thursday morning that no inquest would be held in connection with the crash. He said "he believed" that an inquest was not necessary as how the victims came to their deaths was clear.

Symington Was Pilot

Fred Symington of Ackley was the pilot of the ill fated plane, which he had purchased last spring. The bodies of the four passengers, Ed and Vaney Libersky of St. Ansgar and Marvin Miller and Gladys Ueker of Grafton, were burned beyond recognition. Only the metal parts of the plane, badly charred, remained of the ship.

Ervin Meyer of Ackley accompanied Symington on his flight from Ackley to St. Ansgar. Meyer stated Symington found the motor in "perfect condition" and then started taking up passengers attending the holiday celebration for $1.00 a ride. He took up many passengers during the afternoon before the tragedy occurred.

[MASON CITY GLOBE GAZETTE JULY 5, 1934]

Webization by K. Kittleson
updated 1/13/2010